While part of the message is good, the execution is downright disturbing. I felt the same way. Remaking an animated film in live-action implies framing the tale in a more realistic light. Coachman is the real MVP on the villain side. He sneers, What do I look like, a jackass?. 3,177, This story has been shared 2,881 times. As you point out, many of the more recent films tie up all the loose ends or even offer perspectives that explain why bad behavior is a reaction to some other inequality (Im thinking of Maleficent here). . The temptations the fairy warned against seem to be affecting even our guide. The very night the Blue Fairy gives life to Pinocchio, Geppetto tucks him into bed, because he has to go to school tomorrow. Along with Pinocchio, all the 'bad' kids are lured to the island. I hated this movie as a kid. Then after their hangover, they are turned into donkeys, have their clothes ripped off of them, and then are shipped off to who knows where to work as donkeys! The reason for him to die in the end may have been intended to replicate the transformation from a caterpillar to a butterfly-the death of Pinocchio is probably supposed to be like a butterfly in its chrysalis. The PARADISO is considered the most perfect part of the hereafter where the souls are permitted to live eternally if they can successfully complete the very difficult Celestial Examination process engaging the intellectual and personal guilt and forgiveness requirements system. 1,468, This story has been shared 1,006 times. But a key thing about this sacrifice is that it continues to fit the occult quest narrative, that is, he was still rejecting his conscience and following his will while he did it. Well you all know the story, right. That house looks exactly like the white house? What to Know About 'The Bachelor' Season 27, Episode 6 Filming Location, Mark Wahlbergs "Checkered Racist Past" Has Fans Questioning Why He Presented 'Everything, Everywhere, All at Once' Cast With SAG Award, Stream It Or Skip It: 'National Geographic Investigates: Colombian Hippo Invasion' on Hulu, Where Vets Are Trying To Manage A Species Displaced, 'The Weeknd: Live At Sofi Stadium' Finds The Singer Alone At Center Stage, Hallelujah: Leonard Cohen, a Journey, a Song Charts Complicated Route From Creation to Mass Acceptance, Stream It Or Skip It: There We Were, Now Here We Are: The Making Of Oasis, A Look Backward From The Perspective Of 2004, Stream It Or Skip It: 'Dionne Warwick: Dont Make Me Over' on HBO Max, An Interesting, Career-Spanning Survey Of A Veteran Performer With A Singular Voice And Style, Disney100 Funko Pops Are Here, And They're Adorable, Stream It Or Skip It: Lyle Lyle Crocodile on Netflix, an Extremely Silly Musical About a Singing Reptile, Stream It Or Skip It: Paws of Fury: The Legend of Hank on Prime Video, the Animated Kid-Friendly Version of 'Blazing Saddles' You Didn't Know You Didn't Need, Stream It Or Skip It: True Spirit on Netflix, A Movie Based On The True Story of a Teen's Global Sailing Voyage, 'The Last of Us' Episode 7 Recap: Mallrats, Yes, Ellie Has Always Been Gay in 'The Last of Us', Who Plays Riley in 'The Last of Us'? Related: Disney's Pinocchio Remake Avoids 1 Live-Action Mistake. Quick summary: Pinocchio is lured by the bad foxes, gets sold to a guy in entertainment biz, he escapes, lured by foxes again, then sold to a guy who is going to take him to "pleasure island" (yes, that's the real name of island in movie). Now I look at everything more skeptically than I did before and I was already a skeptic. I appreciate most of your thoughts and praise of the art of the film. Not one of the villains in this film gets what they have coming. Good way to get our grandparents primed for things to come, right? A few thoughts here. It means a lot. 602, This story has been shared 559 times. Monstro isnt really a villain hes just an animal looking for food. This is mostly a Pinocchio story problem, and Zemeckis's film makes up for it somewhat in craft - the spectacle of Pleasure Island is visually dazzling, same for Pinocchio and Geppetto's . However, this time he did it "right" and there's a couple of levels of metaphor to really reinforce that he completed his occult quest. There was a storybook of bambi I read with my grandmother as a child I still have which hinted the possibility she wasnt dead it said something like the hunter had caught her and now Bambi was all alone. Acting is not a distinguished career no matter how much press they get. I shouldve added that. Polaris, or the North Star, is found in which constellation? The semi-realistic, furry, donkey face is infinitely more grotesque. Later, there are explicit messages dark enough for a childs mind and darker for an adults mind. They drink, they smoke, they fight, they destroy stuff and then they become donkeys and therefore, scarred for life. But if all of that wasn't explicit enough there's actually a literal death where Pinocchio isn't breathing and then recovers from drowning. I did not know about Jews then, but I know now. And in this film, the main characters prosper by way of goodness and faith. Jiminy is an original character based on an unnamed talking cricket who tries and fails to advise Pinocchio in the book. In Collodis book, Pinocchio ends up killing the cricket with a hammer, and all of his subsequent appearances in the novel are as a ghost. Season 5 Return Date Info, Love 'Yellowstone'? No matter what kind of mistakes he makes or what kind of choices he makes she is there to help guide him the best she can. Otherwise, the truth the viewer must face is too terrible. Then what? thats what I get for being sleep deprived. You honestly dont call that distinguished or successful? The injustices towards animals are as real and now as they were then. Pinocchio manages to escape this fate, though his friend Lampwick is transformed. Both are important to think about and no one said they are mutually exclusive. Just want to know what you guys think? Children dressing up as drag queens, homophobia hour, how to put a condom on, and the latest computer game version of battling soldiers are cool, hip, and just peachy ok. There is no way to argue against that totally does like the story of the pied piper. Seeing a dark coat makes many think that there is no need to look behind something already so explicit. I WATCHED THIS MOVIE LAST NIGHT FOR THE FIRST TIME SINCE IN ALMOST 20 YEARS.. Im 26 now.. and the movie freaked me out last night more than it did when I was a kid. Honest John once again lures the gullible Pinocchio into a trap by giving him the false diagnosis that he is ill and in need of a vacation to Pleasure Island. He's still made of pine, but he can move, talk, and kinda walk. Eventually he reaches perfection, and perfection in this case is shown to be self-sacrifice, true love to save his master Gepetto. I came away from it feeling sick. But seeing this scene in all its live-action-CGI-hybrid glory makes it so much worse. ), even though Pinocchio doesn't even know what other kids are, much less what school is for. This is an interesting take on the film. Pinocchio begins to believe that he is a victim and can't resist the prospect of getting away from responsibility for a while. he got put into the world blindly and bluntly and got one too many curve balls thrown at him, such as life. In any case, he goes about his quest. In Pinocchio, it only gets harder. I never read the book. Jiminy, again, encourages him to simply be truthful. follow your gut instinct, if something doesnt feel right (Honest john, Stromboli, The Coachmen) etc, then it probably isnt.. since Pinocchio didnt have parents to upbring him with values, morals, etc. Remember how they were enslaved in England in coal mines and / or weaving factories, etc. The rest they are put to work like slaves and those who have even the capability to protest the conditions they are put in aresilenced. Remember the first time Honest John manipulates Pinoke and Jiminy for a second looks at the camera and goes oh no! Product Type All Product Types ; Books (18) Magazines & Periodicals; Comics; Sheet Music . RKO Radio Pictures / Walt Disney Animation Studios. The circus exploiting him..the people making fun. One wonders how adults let children watch this movie? Also, as a child I was horrified of the donkey scene and it still til this day watching it years later meant a general visceral nightmare painting a picture of a specific crime is outside the realm of whats shown. After all, by that point in the recollection, Pinocchio had ignored his conscience. A boy who wont be good may just as well be made of wood.. Turns out Im not crazy. The Initation. At this point, Pinocchio has enough experience to know how to move forward on his own. And Disney is trying to teach little boys (and girls) the lesson of life AND TAKING RESPONSIBILITY for your own actions and not blame others, but be accountable. This is the first time in the movie that Pinocchio turned down temptation and misbehavior, which is something that the other children were not able to do. Honest John is not so terrified of Stromboli because this last one has shown his true nature to no one but Pinocchio,Monstro as a whale behaving in contrast with his nature is,according to Disney,the evil in the body of an animali, thats why is a whale and not a shark or dogfish like in the Collodis book. Also, his nose doesn't grow when he lies any more. This is a kids story about a evil man taking little kids, a story for kids. Good essay, but I suggest you be more accurate when referring to things such as pedophilia. Labeled by the movie as one of the stupid little boys the Coachman was after, Pinocchio takes him up on the offer. People do not listen to their conscience, the vast majority of humans in the movie are terrible, even kids Pinocchios own age go astray, and Pinocchio is nonetheless asked to become the lone light in a sea of darkness. The best way to hide something dark is to coat it with something dark. He is also a pedophile. You see, everything the Blue Fairy tell Pinocchio is true. Nothing is more devastating for a child than the loss of their mother. Once Pinocchio begins listening to his conscience and being true to himself, he and his loved ones are able to prosper at the end of the movie. For that reason, Pinocchio himself (and the fairy who helps him) may be the extent of . To hear you talk, Lampwick says, in an accent that is an unholy mix of Cockney British and Newsies, youd think something terrible is going to happen to us., Then, in an almost shot-for-shot remake of the original scene, he sprouts donkey ears, quickly followed by a donkey face. All hopes that director Robert Zemeckis would simply skip over the donkey stuff in this remake were dashed when the CGI Pinocchio followed his misbehaving friend Lampwick (played by Lewin Lloyd) to the hedonistic Pleasure Island. You could say the same of bambi..people are the villains. Ive taken to calling POTUS President Pinocchio. The realisation hits Jiminy when one of the donkeys speaks and begs for its mother that the boys have all been turned into donkeys, and are to be sold into slave labour. If I was teaching that class, I wouldve advised them to pay more attention to Disneys other movies, because many of them have a fair share of dark content. It officially opened on May 1, 1989. . I never quite noticed how awful the people around Pinocchio were. I don't understand why a post like this would be downvoted!? Good stuff. Free shipping for many products! A plump man in a red suit spills piles of gold provided Honest John gets him stupid little boys to take to a place called Pleasure Island, a place John implies is illegal, fearing the law might come after them. ) Maybe (its a point of view that needs to be confirmed) showing moral decay and hellish punishments was seen as a way to divert people from misbehavioring, typical of the Puritan Anglo-saxon mentality and of course very strange (I add, twisted and perverse) for the French (and Latin/Catholic) one. I think the Coachmans comeuppance is that he eventually runs out of stupid little boys for his racket. But do they? 10:06 *This Is MAGICAL!!! They were lies nonetheless told by either Pinocchio or the movie itself. In the case of Pinocchio, this involves an action-packed adventure for the titular puppet as he matures to learn right from wrong in his quest to become a real boy. And she says no. Thus far, the movie has been fine. Perhaps Jiminy was wrong. Pinocchio can live. After wishing on a star, lonely woodcarver Geppettos puppet Pinocchio comes to life. No human in the movie acts like this so it must be assumed that the Blue Fairy wants Pinocchio to be that model. There was many villains in Dumbo. On the subject of his weight loss there have been many conspiracy theories, including divine intervention and liposuction. Pinocchio hung on a tree is an ancient portrayal of crucifixion which typically involved tree imagery (nailed to, tied to, pierced by an arrow below, or hung from). And this system would continue for well over a century, long after the basic BatB story would be resolved. The main point of the film is Pinocchios coming of age, learning from mistakes, saving his master, and finally becoming a boy. He is lured away by Mr. "The Coach to Pleasure Island" is an instrumental song from Disney's 1940 animated classic film Pinocchio. She is the solution to all problems presented: lifeless puppet, overgrown nose, locked cage, man-eating whale, or death. With Ian Sharp, Gina Bramhill, Rick Warden, Nicholas Day. Its very possible I never got into smoking because of how haunting this movie is. Even by the end, the Coachman is not punished, the donkeys are never freed and Stromboli is still out there to abuse other actors and actresses that come his way, Honest John and Gideon will continue luring stupid little boys into their traps, and thats just how the world is. By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. I taught a Disney Films class last year and my students (18-adult) HATED Pinocchio and Dumbo with equal vigor. Strombolis lost forever his little wooden gold mine obtaining much less success than before,probably bankrupt and depressed. The Blue Fairy, who grants Geppettos wish, promises Pinocchio will become a real boy with the stipulation that he acts selfless, truthful, and brave. Good point. 3,335, This story has been shared 3,177 times. He is still learning how to make decisions. It plays when Honest John and Gideon invite Pinocchio to Pleasure Island and when the Coachman is taking him and the other boys to the park. There are stories about a deleted scene in which Honest John and Gideon meet Pinocchio for a third time but are arrested. In some cases, they are in the open. Some dark films for kiddos are really feel-good movies in total, or send an important message that is worth all the darkness. Another important thing to add is The Blue fairy in Pinocchio is teaching him the lesson of life. The kid obviously wasn't ready for school, and Geppetto should have known that. Sep 25, 2021 - Recipes from or inspired by the Disney movie Pinocchio. Was Johns sidekick just there? If you read the origins of why Sesame Street ended the gag of the adults not believing Big Bird about Snuffy, it implies that most kids would WANT TO tell their parents about an experience they were scarred from, because the gag was making kids think that nobody would believe them when they were telling the truth (which Pinocchio promised earlier in the movie to always do). Now obviously all this what happened to Pinocchio was all worst case scenario BUT it sort of prepares one for life on these things can happen. The story of the Metamorphoses bears many resemblances with Pinocchio by its story line, its spiritual allegory and its theme of occult initiation. He uses that rather underhanded tactic to try and ruin George Bailey, and in the end, it is the good will that George has showered on his family and friends that saves the day. And honestly, the fates of those kids disturbed me even as a child but it was not until I became an adult when I realized how dire things were really were for them. Vengence is an old testament outdated solution. Jiminy? In Pinocchio, the truth does hurt and partly because its messages are not implicit at all. Didn't Michael Jackson always talk about Peter Pan and his compound was called Neverland. I found it utterly disturbing, but still love it. Pleasure Island Troupe . Rather than following his fathers wishes and going to school, Pinocchio joins Strombolis puppet show with dreams of becoming famous. 1,006, This story has been shared 907 times. They inform Pinocchio that Stromboli has been arrested for his cruelty towards his employees and that they are taking over the puppet show. The novel depicts him as more obnoxious and short-tempered, and his change in personality was at the request of Walt Disney who feared he would be too unlikeable as a protagonist. Sure, all 8-year olds want to drink and smoke and brawl. Its all well and good that Pinocchio and company survived, but what about the hundreds of kids getting sold into donkey slavery? Well, his conscience is gone, he doesn't need it any more. (Though in all honesty, the real lie was when he said Jiminy was tied too.) Talk about dark; what about when Bambis mother is killed. The same thing happened in the book as well. Yeah but think about it this way the story was not about defeating evil it was about staying away from it or if you do indulge in it consequences will follow. The threat to be made into firewood was certainly there. Honest John and a new villain. We are coming to find out that reality is actually more horrible than fiction Why is this downvoted so hard, even factoring in our regular shifty voting? I have friends who didnt see the Hunchback till later too. Things get absolutely crazy, even for a Disney movie here. Especially if you consider how impressionable the Pleasure Island scenes in the original Disney classic Pinocchio were. Things quickly hit the fan for Pinocchio, Jiminy Cricket, and Geppetto at the end of Pinocchio. We hope to challenge issues which have captured the publics imagination, from JFK and UFOs to 9/11. My next story, " A Shooting Star," is inspired by my relationships as a college theater major.My "Cozzi Cove" series celebrates my glorious summers at the New Jersey Shore. Now everything makes sense. Your article says everything I felt. Pinocchio came on the Disney channel today and I am literally here watching Pinocchio for the first time in years, with my five year old daughter. It does not end there either. you know just like how kids do when they get in trouble they will try to blame their friend or the other guy, but they will learn quick they cannot do this and cannot snitch, for if they dont learn to take responsibility as children they will have a hell of a time as adults. Ive seen it for the first (and only) time at the age of 35, with my children, and I found it very dark and disturbing, perhaps more for the adults than for the children, and surely more than the original Italian novel (!) Is it impossible that a street rat can trick a mad sorcerer into becoming a genie by taking advantage of his pride? Other than the famous nose-extending lie he tells, he is never particularly odious. The donkey scene in the 2022 live-action Pinocchio is somehow even more terrifying than the 1940 animated Pinocchio donkey scene. Back when Pinocchio gets captured by Stromboli and the Blue Fairy rescues him, she says it's the last time she can help him out. Was it really a lie? IN a last ditch effort to appear the victim in the trail of events that he enjoyed up till the end while not going to school as he was told, Pinocchio lies about being chopped into fire woodeven though it is clear that he is whole. I havent seen Pinocchio since I was probably 8 and Im 37 now but its surprising how I instantly recollected the scenes you were describing. This was perceived as a lie, of course but the audience knows better. But take it from someone who loved Pinocchio as a child (and still do as an adult) you dont catch these things. His fur ripples and his Sonic-esque teeth protrude as he grabs Pinocchio by the shoulders. Trust all of them. Never trust them or expose yourself to their works if you value your soul and your joy for living. Escaping Pleasure Island. I envy your participation in such a discussion. Either that or his steamboat is unfortunate enough to be eaten by Monstro, a whale of a whale who has a reputation of eating ships whole. I am very interested. We teach them some fundamental life skills first. Honest John and Gideon are certainly the least intimidating villains in the movie, but they are the ones responsible for putting Pinocchio in the most dangerous situations. Yet the discussion was stifled because nobody could articulate quite why they had such dramatic reactions. One student simply stated, This isnt what Disney is all about, which instigated a great conversation about audience expectations, brand, original material, etc. Ignoring his conscience again, Pinocchio attempts to deceive Blue Fairy with half-truths..escalating to blatant lies. In Disneys version, Pinocchio has a childish curiosity and naivety which is either used for comedic effect or to make him vulnerable to villains. The biggest driving force behind the plot of Disney+s Pinocchio is the Blue Fairys promise to turn Pinocchio into a human child if he is able to remain true, brave, and unselfish. Dies geschieht in Ihren Datenschutzeinstellungen. Although the other children on Pleasure Island are shown transforming fully into donkeys at the end of the live-action Disney remake, Pinocchio escapes Pleasure Island with only donkey ears and a tail. In the animated Pinocchio, the Coachman states that left to their own devices, boys make jackasses of themselves. These lines hold, from the beginning till the end as the most important and oft-spoken lines in the movie. The lesson is that lying cannot protect you, and Pinocchio is destined to endure more dire situations when this becomes apparent. To find the price of a script and/or performance rights, complete this form and click the "Find the Price" button. Sort By . And behind these already dark explicit overtones the movie makes, it cleverly hides something darker, even for adults. However, one Disney movie sets itself apart from the rest. Happily ever after only for some people. Sure he distracts him a lot with his doctor game but in the end he holds him against his will more than once and when they take him away its not willingly. The History and Impact of Modern Cartoons, The Appeal of the female characters in Arcane: League of Legends.