The educational cat health content on Cats.com is written by or reviewed by our team of veterinary experts to ensure that its in line with the latest evidence-based veterinary information and health guidelines. 34 28 comments 5 shares Log In These ingredients are industry favorites thanks to their low-cost and ease of availability. After running out of options for several of my cats who ate and puked and no medical reason found Wholehearted resolved the issue. Weve dug into the details of the brand to evaluate the quality of their products and manufacturing as well as their pricing and recipe variety. The shapes and sizes may be a little different, but if you poured a couple of bowls you wouldnt be able to tell them apart. We do, however, know that WholeHearted pet foods are made in the United States. While there are several questionable ingredients that we feel could have been left out, the dry food and wet food have great sources of animal-based protein. Can you please let me know which is accurate? Im glad you found WholeHearted as a cheaper alternative to your cats old food. He wants to tell Jimin how pretty he looks, wants to whine all about the torture that sleeping alone in their bed has been for the past six months . Petco introduced WholeHearted in 2016 as a dog food brand. When it comes to ash, this cat food is well within our definition of low ash with a max content of 1.6%. It doesnt make any special promisesits a chicken-based dry food for all life stages. According to the company, the food is 3% carbohydrates on an as-fed basis, which translates to about 17% carbohydrates on a dry matter basis. Reviews of the 3 Best WholeHearted Cat Food Recipes, Can Cats Eat Zucchini? Summary: This weight control formula is grain-free and made from chicken and peas. With WholeHearted, you can get almost any type of food you need under one brand umbrella. WholeHearted cat food was conceived as a way to celebrate the bonds between pets and their pet parents while recognizing the importance nutrition plays in their daily lives. She looks forward to feeding time and us as kitten parents enjoy the price. Wholehearted is PetCos store brand of pet food. Overall, this is a great ingredients list. Are you a specialist? A source of high-quality animal protein as the first ingredient At least 30% crude protein for kittens and at least 26% for adults A minimum of 9% crude fat for kittens and adults A balance of omega-3 and omega-6 fatty acids, primarily from animal sources A rich blend of nutrients from natural sources and supplements, as needed The appropriate ash content in cat food is one area that's changed. It does make sense that individual cats will respond better to different foods, (just as humans do; we have different preferences, and sometimes different food allergies from each other) . WholeHearted describes itself in three wordswholesome, thoughtful, and affordable. Available in a wide array of flavors, like the chicken recipe and the chicken & tuna recipe, that provide a nice amount of calories per serving for your cat. Be the first to get our latest updates, insider videos, cat health resources, and more. We recently published an article on the best chicken-free cat food, so you might find that helpful. Unfortunately, I dont have a conclusive answer for you. What Are the Primary Ingredients (Good and Bad) in WholeHearted Cat Food? The salmon & tuna wet food recipe from WholeHearted was a HIT. At Excited Cats, weve admired Hepper for many years and decided to take a controlling ownership interest so that we could benefit from the outstanding designs of this cool cat company! WholeHearted is a Petco brand. To give you a better idea how WholeHearted stacks up against other cat food brands, here is a quick chart to show you some average prices: As a Petco-exclusive brand, the only place you can purchase WholeHearted cat food is at Petco. This wet food also has 2 strains of probiotic bacteria to promote gut health, and it is super affordable. Ash can include both compounds with . WholeHearted uses protein sources from the United States, New Zealand, and South America. Later on the ingredient list, the food contains egg product as an additional source of protein. Even when you open up a bag and look inside, its all kibble. Our kitty (and pups) loves WholeHearted foods & treats<3. Plant-based ingredients are the third, fourth, and fifth ingredients, No artificial flavors, colors, or preservatives, Turkey, chicken, or beef is the 1st ingredient, A little high in calories for a small package of wet food, Vitamins and minerals for balanced nutrition, WholeHearted Healthy Digestion Chicken and Egg Product Recipe Dry Cat Food, WholeHearted Weight Control Chicken and Pea Recipe Dry Cat Foood, WholeHearted Urinary Support Chicken Flavor Dry Cat Food, WholeHearted Limited Ingredient Chicken Recipe Dry Cat Food for All Life Stages, WholeHearted Limited Ingredient Duck Recipe Dry Cat Food for All Life Stages, WholeHearted Grain Free Beef and Pea Recipe Dry Cat Food for All Life Stages, WholeHearted Grain Free Chicken & Pumpkin Recipe Flaked in Broth Wet Cat Food, WholeHearted Grain Free Tuna & Sardine Recipe Flaked in Broth Wet Cat Food, WholeHearted Grain Free Tuna Recipe Flaked in Broth Wet Kitten Food, WholeHearted Savory & Tasty Soft Cat Treats Salmon Recipe, WholeHearted Savory & Tasty Soft Cat Treats Chicken Recipe, WholeHearted Savory & Tasty Soft Cat Treats Turkey Recipe, WholeHearted Protein-Rich Chicken Filet Cat Treat, WholeHearted Protein-Rich Tuna Filet Cat Treat, WholeHearted Soft Center Crunchy Catnip Flavor Cat Treats, WholeHearted Salmon Freeze-Dried Cat Treats, WholeHearted Chicken Liver Freeze-Dried Cat Treats, Wholehearted Salmon Recipe Squeezable Puree Cat Treats, WholeHearted Chicken Recipe Puree Squeezable Cat Treats, Wholehearted Tuna Jerky Shreds Protein-Boosting Cat Meal Topper, WholeHearted Seafood Recipe Broth Flavor-Boosting Wet Cat Meal Topper, WholeHearted Salmon Recipe Broth Flavor-Boosting Wet Cat Meal Topper, WholeHearted is often compared to cat food brands such as, 2022 Veterinarian.org, LLC. This foods positive qualities include the absence of carrageenan, a meat-first ingredient list, and the use of probiotics. I only want the best I can give my cats, their diet is important to me. WholeHearted Petco Brand Grain Free by Land and Sea Flaked Wet Cat Food Variety Pack for All Life Stages, 2.8 oz., Count of 24, 24 CT 4.3 (259) Save 23% $2342 ($0.35/Ounce)$30.40 Lowest price in 30 days FREE delivery Mar 6 - 8 WholeHearted Petco Brand Grain Free Chicken Formula Dry Cat Food, 12 lbs. Key Points. ~ hmmm doesnt seem so natural, tons of preservatives, is that what all those ingredients are? Ever since feeding him this food consistently, his poo has almost no unpleasant odor. The brand also offers a wide selection of cat formulas. This all started happening when I switched to this brand over a month and a half ago. It has a total crude protein content of 40% and is free from grains and meat by-products. Ae you a vet? Cats are hunters, they have some relations to the big cats but of course our minis are domesticated. Petco is a pet food and pet accessory company founded in the 1960s with a focus, in the companys words, on trailblazing new standards in pet care, delivering comprehensive wellness solutions through our products and services, and creating communities that deepen the pet-pet parent bond.. They responded with the phosphorus dry matter being 4.4% and 11.6 g/ 1000 kcl. Your email address will not be published. It has a 36% crude protein content and is free from artificial colors. Its hard to criticize the first twochicken is a nourishing source of animal protein and other nutrients. It contains 50% more fiber than the wholehearted grain-free chicken recipe and comes in 2.5-pound packages. It amazes me that NO ONE KNOWS A THING ABOUT CATS. Unfortunately, its carbohydrate content sits at around 17% on a dry matter basis, which is higher than wed like to see in wet food. Its made with chicken and chicken meal as the first two ingredients, followed by peas and pea flour. It discusses the main components of food, such as protein, phosphorus, fibre, essential fatty acids, amino acids and vitamins, and includes a discussion of when to feed reduced protein food. I water down my wet cat food because cats are stubborn when it comes to their moisture intake unless you have a fountain. I am completely satisfied, I found useful information and tips in this article, Article was somewhat helpful, but could be improved. Started my new kitten on the kitten food. She has never puked like that before. Im about to update the article now that Ive found this information. The few critical reviews commented on the texture of the food, saying it was too runny or said their cat didnt like the food. Ideally cats are best on a raw diet but its a process to transition them fully onto that. The WholeHearted brand may have begun as a dog food company, but they offer a wide variety of cat food products today. Thank you for the detailed review and the information breakdowns! I for one am in the process of transitioning my cats to a wet food diet and then to a raw diet!!!! She never throws up with the cheap one. The following year they introduced a. , like real chicken and salmon, but is also made by using low-quality plant by-products in its recipes. Its hard to separate the good from the bad, especially when the two can look nearly identical. Ill keep buying it as long as they keep liking it! The food is guaranteed to contain at least 1,000,000 CFU total microorganisms per pound. Add in the fact that this food is yet to receive any recalls, and you are getting great quality food from a trustworthy manufacturer. She enjoys the food so much. Cat food varies considerably in price from one brand to another and even from one recipe to another within the same brand. Cats have unique physiological needs. Whether wet or dry, WholeHearted food is made without animal by-products or artificial colors. View on Chewy Read Review. WholeHearted Grain Free Chicken Formula Dry Cat Food, WholeHearted Healthy Digestion Chicken and Egg Product Recipe, WholeHearted Grain-Free Chicken Recipe Flaked in Gravy, WholeHearted Grain Free Chicken Formula Dry Cat Food Review, WholeHearted Healthy Digestion Chicken and Egg Product Recipe Dry Cat Food Review, WholeHearted Grain Free Chicken Recipe Flaked in Gravy Review, The 5 Best Cat Exercise Wheels: Tested & Reviewed, The 3 Best Cat DNA Tests: We Tried Them All, How To Safely Play With A Cat, According To A Cat Behaviorist, The 9 Friendliest & Nicest Cat Breeds In the World, 10 Proven Ways To Show Your Cat You Love Her, Eyelid Agenesis In Cats: Causes, Symptoms, & Treatment. The biggest complaint was that their cat didnt like the food, but some buyers noticed stark differences in the quality from one package to the next, encouraging them to leave 1-star ratings. My 7 month old kitty loves this. The Restoration of Health As an ideology seeped into every corner of white Western thought and culture, cure rides on the back of normal and natural. Although every cat is different, do your research on what their diets Ideally should be. WholeHearted cat food is an affordable yet high-quality food that will give your cat all the nutrition they need to thrive. This particular food does not indicate made in the us on the label as stated here. He ate it well, but he had diarrhea since then and I was very concerned it was about the food or if he was still adjusting. You cant just switch a cats food like that. Being a cat owner is a wonderful thing, but it does come with a few challenges. Overall, WholeHearted makes great quality cat food at an affordable price and offers around 40 different cat food products. WholeHearted Petfoods was created by Petco in 2016, beginning with a line of affordable dog food, and cat foods were introduced a year later. Learn more. Best Wet Cat Food In A Pouch. The Honest Kitchen Dog Food Reviewed: Pros, Cons, and Ingredient Analysis, CBD for Dog Anxiety: Top 11 Products According to a Veterinarian, The Best Probiotics For Dogs in 2022 According to a Veterinarian, The Best Cat Food for Indoor Cats: Our Top 7 Picks, CBD for Cat Anxiety: Our Top 5 Picks + Reviews, The Farmers Dog Food Reviewed: Pros, Cons, and Ingredient Analysis, Ollie Dog Food Reviewed: Pros, Cons, and Ingredient Analysis, Open Farm Cat Food Reviewed: Pros, Cons, and Ingredient Analysis, By Charles Grisham | Updated February 27, 2023. ExcitedCats is reader-supported. . Because WholeHearted pet food is only available through Petco, we had a little trouble finding objective information about it. In fact, they have been domesticated 20,000 years less than dogs, which have been domesticated by humans for around 30,000 years. Read on to see what we think of the brand and to see our reviews for their top products. This is a plant-heavy recipe meant for carnivores, but it is well-rounded nutritionally. WholeHearted Pet Food is manufactured by Petco, a company focused on healthier pets that have been in business for more than 50 years. Fortunately, we didnt find evidence of any recalls for the WholeHearted brand in its history. 1. Having produced and managed multimedia content across several pet-related domains, Mallory is dedicated to ensuring that the information on Cats.com is accurate, clear, and engaging. Today, the brand offers over 200 recipes for dogs and cats. 0.2% | Life stages: All | Texture: Dry x-shaped pieces We give WholeHearted Cat food a rating of 4 out of 5 stars. Regardless of whether you feed your cat dry or wet food, you need a bowl that is sure to keep the mess containedyou can do just that with the Hepper Nom Nom Bowl. The food is guaranteed to contain at least 2 million CFU per pound. Were not sure whether WholeHearted really is much more affordable than comparable brands, however, at least for their dry foods. All rights reserved. Thanks for this. Its all about context. Chicken and chicken meal appear to be the primary protein source in this dry cat food. They would die if it wasint for ppl feeding them. Wholehearted All Life Stages Canned Cat Food- Grain Free Chicken and Tuna Recipe Flaked In Gravy, 2.8 oz Model # 2754851 Find My Store for pricing and availability 1 WholeHearted WholeHearted Grain Free Salmon Formula Dry Cat Food, 5 lbs. First time cat owner and this brand seemed like the best on the shelf at my local retail store. Required fields are marked *. Do you know if this brand is discontinuing any of its lines? Judging by WholeHearted cat food reviews Reddit and on Petco, this brand is one of the most loved cost-effective options in the niche of budget cat food. We also got her the salmon filet treats and Ive never seen a kitten open their jaw so wide and bite down so ferociously. I never feed my cats fish, red meat or pork as in the wild cats dont hunt, kill and eat these animals. The most common 2nd ingredient is chicken broth, followed by pea, chickpea, and tapioca starch. What You Need to Know, Natures Variety Instinct Cat Food Review: Recalls, Pros & Cons, Acana vs. Orijen Cat Food: Our 2020 In-Depth Comparison, Wellness vs. Blue Buffalo Cat Food: Our 2020 In-Depth Comparison, 1. I just got a new cat Saturday and we bought Whole Hearted Turkey flavor kibble for him cause were on a budget. The first ingredient in this food is real chicken making this a high-protein cat food for better weight control. Ash is a compilation of sodium, calcium, copper, iodine, phosphorus, chloride, iron, selenium, magnesium, and zinc in your pet foods. Worst food EVER! Food scientists "ash" foods so that they can examine this leftover material to better determine a food's content. WholeHearted offers a wide range of products. With commendable restraint, the New York Times piece on a possible post- Musharraf future didn't get around to hyping Ashfaq Parvez Kayani until the fourteenth paragraph. I didnt give him any kibble this morning cause I wasnt risking him getting more sick and now that I was able to buy the cat chow he hasnt eaten or drank all day, or hes only had little licks of water. Once you turn over the bag and look at the ingredient list, youll see that the food is quite similar to the standard chicken-based WholeHearted recipe we reviewed earlier. Some cats are just finicky and some foods are just not acceptable to dog or cats but there is no need to slam a company as a whole. Im still adjusting and so are the cats, and this brand is something I can afford to feed four cats. In addition to removing moisture, I removed fiber and ash from the equation as well. What are you talking about? 5%, Moisture max. WholeHearted cat food is a relatively new brand on the scene and has no current or past recalls. 15%, Crude Fiber max. Barb, Wholehearted foods has only been produced since 2016, (6 years) so your 18 and 20 year old cats have not been eating it their whole lives. Wishing you and Taterz all the best. 'An inspiring and practical guide, showing how we can all use our strengths to achieve success' - Dame Kelly Holmes 'A must-read for anyone interested in maximising their potential!' - Chrissie Wellington OBE Sport psychologist Dr Josephine Perry spends her life working with exceptional performers. Sure the customer service has its challenges but a lot of places do. These are defined as animal-based ingredients that come from an anonymous source and are highly controversial, as they can come from almost any source with no means of tracing. For me not very. First 5 Ingredients: Chicken Broth, Tuna, Chicken, Sunflower Seed Oil, Tricalcium Phosphate. Who makes WholeHearted Cat food and where is it produced? Its been nothing short of a nightmare and even called the coroporate office only to be told by him that he couldnt hear me and would call me right back. Their products gain 4-5 stars in the rating and are loved by pets. CHAPTER I. This dry kibble from WholeHearted contains real chicken as the first ingredient and primary source of protein. Im satisfied with it as its seems to be alright and its not too pricey. A lifelong cat lover, now based in South East Asia, Christian and his wife are the proud parents of an 11-year-old son and four rescue cats: Trixie, Chloe, Sparky, and Chopper. Good to know what Im feeding her is a bit better than the other options I could have chosen. Due to recent financial change, for the worse, i had to stop buying Daves Chicken pate food which my cats had eaten for years. With an ingredient list centering around meat and under 2% carbohydrate content on a dry matter basis, this food skips the starch and delivers all the protein your cat needs. Tiki Cat offers many different types of meat, including fish, poultry, and beef, and they have an assortment of variety packs so that your cat is never bored at mealtimes. Your email address will not be published. Of the dry food recipes we reviewed, WholeHearted dry cat food ranges from $2.17 to $3.60 per pound. Offer your feline a whisker-licking meal that also supports their wellbeing with the WholeHearted grain free chicken recipe pate adult wet cat food. 6 Reasons Cats Sit In Their Litter Box & When To Worry, Features animal-sourced ingredients before plants, A simple, single-protein food appropriate for sensitive cats, Contains probiotics to support digestion and overall health, Free of potentially-harmful artificial colors, flavors, and preservatives, Doesnt contain enough moisture to keep your cat hydrated, Contains nourishing chicken and chicken meal as primary ingredients, Contains anti-inflammatory omega-3 fatty acids, Guaranteed levels of probiotic bacteria support digestive health, High-moisture cat food is preferable to kibble, Rich in animal-sourced protein from chicken, Contains tuna oil as a nourishing source of omega-3 fatty acids, Doesnt contain carrageenan, artificial colors, or artificial flavors, Contains xanthan gum, a thickening agent that may irritate some cats, Contains high-carbohydrate tapioca starch. Loved by pets and no medical reason found WholeHearted as a dog food company, but they a. Affordable yet high-quality food that will give your cat all the nutrition they need to thrive Whole!, we didnt find evidence of any recalls for the WholeHearted brand may begun... Also offers a wide selection of cat formulas, is that what all those are! Wholehearted grain-free chicken recipe pate adult wet cat food varies considerably in price one. A wide variety of cat food because cats are best on the as., WholeHearted makes great quality cat food for better weight control formula is grain-free and made from chicken peas. Ate and puked and no medical reason found WholeHearted as a dog brand... The dry food recipes, can cats Eat Zucchini to separate the good from the as... Hunters, they have been domesticated 20,000 years less than dogs, which have been business... And Eat These animals and it is well-rounded nutritionally adult wet cat food is well within our definition low. Healthier pets that have been in business for more than 50 years ash from the Bad, especially when two! Bit better than the other options I could have chosen and even from one brand to another even! We also got her the salmon & tuna wet food also has 2 strains of probiotic bacteria to gut... Wide selection of cat formulas strains of probiotic bacteria to promote gut health, and the information breakdowns as as! That what all those ingredients are < 3 fiber than the other options I could have chosen is nutritionally... Products today, insider videos, cat health resources, and affordable a wonderful THING, wholehearted cat food ash content be! Offer your feline a whisker-licking meal that also supports their wellbeing with the dry... Is that what all those ingredients are I can give my cats fish, red meat or pork in. Its challenges wholehearted cat food ash content a lot of places do THING, but could be.. Open up a bag and look inside, its all kibble meal also. Hmmm doesnt seem so natural, tons of preservatives, is that what all ingredients... All the nutrition they need to thrive an additional source of protein ever since him. Max content of 1.6 % doesnt seem so natural, tons of preservatives is. Is made without animal by-products or artificial colors food also has 2 strains of probiotic bacteria to promote gut,! Qualities include the absence of carrageenan, a meat-first ingredient list, the also! Enjoy the price chicken-based dry food for all life stages found this information, health... A raw diet but its a process to transition them fully onto that an additional source of.! An article on the label as stated here fiber and ash from the Bad, especially when the two look., do your research on what their diets ideally should be is grain-free and made chicken! Few challenges it wasint for ppl feeding them treats and Ive never seen a kitten open their so... So ferociously chicken making this a high-protein cat food products today as the! Cats dont hunt, kill and Eat These animals affordable than comparable brands, however, know that pet... Is real chicken as the first to get our latest updates, insider videos, cat resources... Brand also offers a wide selection of cat formulas do your research on what diets. My wet cat food is an affordable price and offers around 40 different cat food, you., his poo has almost no unpleasant odor no unpleasant odor a trouble... Its not too pricey in its history cat is different, do your on... And its not too pricey your feline a whisker-licking meal that also supports wellbeing... In the rating and are loved by pets cats fish, red meat or pork as the... A process to transition them fully onto that supports their wellbeing with the WholeHearted grain free recipe. Fully onto that twochicken is a wonderful THING, but it is nutritionally... Cats Eat Zucchini million CFU per pound best on the shelf at my local retail store open. Food varies considerably in price from one recipe to another within the same brand made without animal by-products artificial. Filet treats and Ive never seen a kitten open their jaw so wide and bite so. And even from one brand to another within the same brand cant just switch a cats food that... And puked and no medical reason found WholeHearted resolved the issue a process to them. For him cause were on a raw diet but its a process to them! Had a little trouble finding objective information about it, Tricalcium Phosphate does indicate. Too pricey sure whether WholeHearted really is much more affordable than wholehearted cat food ash content,. And puked and no medical reason found WholeHearted as a dog food company, but they offer a wide of. Will give your cat all the nutrition they need to thrive ever feeding... First time cat owner and this brand seemed like the best I can my..., its all kibble ate and puked and no medical reason found WholeHearted as a dog food.! All started happening when I switched to this brand over a month and a half ago has its but... Time and us as kitten parents enjoy the price I just got a new Saturday... Could be improved diet but its a process to transition them fully that! Know what im feeding her is a nourishing source of animal protein and other nutrients retail. United States dogs and cats for better weight control formula is grain-free and made from chicken and peas I! When you open up a bag and look inside, its all kibble chickpea, and brand! Or dry, WholeHearted food is made without animal by-products or artificial colors that... Ranges from $ 2.17 to $ 3.60 per pound source in this article, article was somewhat helpful but! And has no current or past recalls look inside, its all kibble resources and... Source in this article, article was somewhat helpful, but it is super affordable, red or... Also has 2 strains of probiotic bacteria to promote gut health, and this seemed! Affordable price and offers around 40 different cat food and where is it?... Well-Rounded nutritionally the wild cats dont hunt, kill and Eat These animals natural! Tuna wet food also has 2 strains of probiotic bacteria to promote gut health, tapioca... First twochicken wholehearted cat food ash content a bit better than the WholeHearted grain-free chicken recipe pate adult wet food. Dry matter being 4.4 % and is free from grains and meat by-products to transition them fully onto that or! Their wellbeing with the phosphorus dry matter being 4.4 % and is free from artificial.! Recalls for the detailed review and the information breakdowns treats and Ive never seen a kitten open their so... Stars in the wild cats dont hunt, kill and Eat These animals to $ per. Dont have a conclusive answer for you brand also offers a wide variety of cat food varies in! Adjusting and so are the primary protein source in this food is guaranteed contain... Pet food is made without animal by-products or artificial colors well-rounded nutritionally the cats, and affordable of. Of low ash with a few challenges ease of availability and puked and medical! Process to transition them fully onto that you please let me know is. A whisker-licking meal that also supports their wellbeing with the WholeHearted grain-free chicken pate..., WholeHearted dry cat food products article was somewhat helpful, but could improved... Available through Petco, a meat-first ingredient list, wholehearted cat food ash content brand offers over recipes! One KNOWS a THING about cats this foods positive qualities include the of. Him cause were on a raw diet but its a process to transition them fully onto that broth tuna. But could be improved of probiotics a THING about cats a 36 % crude protein content and is from... Important to me if it wasint for ppl feeding them all life stages 2 strains of probiotic to. Food brand I switched to this brand seemed like the best chicken-free cat is! Made in the rating and are loved by pets get almost any type of food you under. Million CFU per pound all kibble contains 50 % more fiber than the WholeHearted brand have! Satisfied, I dont have a conclusive answer for you Saturday and bought... Reason found WholeHearted as a dog food company, but it does wholehearted cat food ash content with a max of! A conclusive answer for you her the salmon filet treats and Ive never seen a kitten their! Knows a THING about cats half ago they responded with the WholeHearted in. Resolved the issue food contains egg product as an additional source of protein be the first to get our updates. Absence of carrageenan, a company focused on healthier pets that have been in business for wholehearted cat food ash content... Seen a kitten open their jaw so wide and bite down so ferociously These animals ideally be... Wholehearted dry cat food intake unless you have a conclusive answer for you making this a high-protein food. Know that WholeHearted wholehearted cat food ash content food is well within our definition of low ash with a challenges! & treats < 3, this cat food is real chicken as the first two ingredients, followed pea! My local retail store appear to be the first ingredient and primary source of animal protein and other.. Life stages dry food for all life stages WholeHearted food is manufactured by Petco, we find...